View Single Post
Old 09-28-2006, 08:59 AM   #16
polishshooter
Advanced Senior Member
 
polishshooter's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2001
Location: Indiana
Contributor
Posts: 7,860
Default Re: Best Civil War General

And "Oh By the Way..."

WHY isn't Winfield Scott on the list?

As C in C of ALL Union forces for most of the war, HE and HE ALONE foresaw the strategy needed to WIN, and submitted it EARLY, and EVERYONE in the Union army "pooh-poohed" it as the ramblings of an 80 year old senile mind...

But the "Old Man's" "Anaconda Plan" is almost PRESCIENT in it's predictions, and ultimately is WHAT the North DID to the South....


I guess when you are in your 80s, drooling a little spittle out of your mouth, and having STAINS on your 20 year old outdated uniform, and walk with a cane, all the "youngsters" in both officer corps AND the newspapermen on BOTH sides, much less the HISTORIANS HAVE to ignore you and put the "dashing" Lees and McClellans in their IMMACULATE uniforms and prancing steeds on their front pages....

HELL, Scott COMMANDED just about every "great" General on BOTH sides in his masterfully conducted "last" of the "18th Century" campaigns in Mexico in the 1840s, and even HE grasped that what he did in Mexico was outdated...he KNEW them, WARTS and ALL....

About the ONLY General on either side that also grasped it TOO was Grant....




Old Age and Trickery beats youth and skill any day of the week....
__________________
The problems we face today are
there because the people who work
for a living are outnumbered by those
who vote for a living.

Last edited by polishshooter; 09-28-2006 at 09:02 AM..
polishshooter is offline   Reply With Quote