View Single Post
Old 01-30-2009, 05:33 PM   #42
ivanthehunter
Member
 
Join Date: Aug 2008
Posts: 7
Default Re: which is better .17 hmr or .17 mach 2

Quote:
Originally Posted by lb969 View Post
One of the advantages to the .17 HM2 is that its based off a .22 cartridge, and therefore you can get refit kits to change a .22LR to a .17HM2. I think Ruger has some for their 10/22.


Just in case yall were wondering...


.17 HM2 vs. .17 HMR



I'm waiting on buying a .17 myself (until a clear winner between all the different .17's are settled), but I was wondering what the opinion of the .17 Fireball is?
From what i can gather the fireball provides shooting out to 300yards but again why bother with this light bullet thats trying to fight its way out to 300yards in the wind when the 22-250 or the 220swift(poss a nice 223wssm or a 270) will do the same range with much better resistance to wind and as all these round are in the 4000 fps area they all suffer fouling. Fouling of a thousand of an inch in a 224 barrel will not amount to much as a total % of the bore diameter but this % will be much larger than with the smaller calibers of the .17's(high speed 4000 fps area only) ultimately this effect sustained accuracy unless its countered by cleaning and maybe some special cocktail to coat the inside the bore to reduce friction or sometime else in the black magic area

The Jacketed HM2 and the HMR with their jacketed construction and lower velocities avoid this fouling.
ivanthehunter is offline   Reply With Quote