The poor in America - How do they live?

[45nut]

Article and full report here


Executive Summary Today, the Census Bureau released its annual poverty report, which declared that a record 46.2 million persons, or roughly one in seven Americans, were poor in 2010. The numbers were up sharply from the previous year’s total of 43.6 million. Although the current recession has increased the numbers of the poor, high levels of poverty predate the recession. In most years for the past two decades, the Census Bureau has declared that at least 35 million Americans lived in poverty.

However, understanding poverty in America requires looking behind these numbers at the actual living conditions of the individuals the government deems to be poor. For most Americans, the word “poverty” suggests near destitution: an inability to provide nutritious food, clothing, and reasonable shelter for one’s family. However, only a small number of the 46 million persons classified as “poor” by the Census Bureau fit that description. While real material hardship certainly does occur, it is limited in scope and severity.

The following are facts about persons defined as “poor” by the Census Bureau as taken from various government reports:

* 80 percent of poor households have air conditioning. In 1970, only 36 percent of the entire U.S. population enjoyed air conditioning.
* 92 percent of poor households have a microwave.
* Nearly three-fourths have a car or truck, and 31 percent have two or more cars or trucks.
* Nearly two-thirds have cable or satellite TV.
* Two-thirds have at least one DVD player, and 70 percent have a VCR.
* Half have a personal computer, and one in seven have two or more computers.
* More than half of poor families with children have a video game system, such as an Xbox or PlayStation.
* 43 percent have Internet access.
* One-third have a wide-screen plasma or LCD TV.
* One-fourth have a digital video recorder system, such as a TiVo.

For decades, the living conditions of the poor have steadily improved. Consumer items that were luxuries or significant purchases for the middle class a few decades ago have become commonplace in poor households, partially because of the normal downward price trend that follows introduction of a new product.

Liberals use the declining relative prices of many amenities to argue that it is no big deal that poor households have air conditioning, computers, cable TV, and wide-screen TV. They contend, polemically, that even though most poor families may have a house full of modern conveniences, the average poor family still suffers from substantial deprivation in basic needs, such as food and housing. In reality, this is just not true.

Although the mainstream media broadcast alarming stories about widespread and severe hunger in the nation, in reality, most of the poor do not experience hunger or food shortages. The U.S. Department of Agriculture collects data on these topics in its household food security survey. For 2009, the survey showed:

* 96 percent of poor parents stated that their children were never hungry at any time during the year because they could not afford food.

* 83 percent of poor families reported having enough food to eat.
* 82 percent of poor adults reported never being hungry at any time in the prior year due to lack of money for food.

Other government surveys show that the average consumption of protein, vitamins, and minerals is virtually the same for poor and middle-class children and is well above recommended norms in most cases.

Television newscasts about poverty in America generally portray the poor as homeless people or as a destitute family living in an overcrowded, dilapidated trailer. In fact, however:

* Over the course of a year, 4 percent of poor persons become temporarily homeless.
* Only 9.5 percent of the poor live in mobile homes or trailers, 49.5 percent live in separate single-family houses or townhouses, and 40 percent live in apartments.
* 42 percent of poor households actually own their own homes.

* Only 6 percent of poor households are overcrowded. More than two-thirds have more than two rooms per person.

* The average poor American has more living space than the typical non-poor person in Sweden, France, or the United Kingdom.
* The vast majority of the homes or apartments of the poor are in good repair.

By their own reports, the average poor person had sufficient funds to meet all essential needs and to obtain medical care for family members throughout the year whenever needed.

Of course, poor Americans do not live in the lap of luxury. The poor clearly struggle to make ends meet, but they are generally struggling to pay for cable TV, air conditioning, and a car, as well as for food on the table. The average poor person is far from affluent, but his lifestyle is far from the images of stark deprivation purveyed by advocacy groups and the media.

Moreover, the fact that the average poor household has many modern conveniences and experiences no substantial hardships does not mean that no families face hardships. As noted, the overwhelming majority of the poor are well housed and not overcrowded, but one in 25 will become temporarily homeless during the year. While most of the poor have a sufficient and fairly steady supply of food, one in five poor adults will experience temporary food shortages and hunger at some point in a year.

The poor man who has lost his home or suffers intermittent hunger will find no consolation in the fact that his condition occurs infrequently in American society. His hardships are real and must be an important concern for policymakers. Nonetheless, anti-poverty policy needs to be based on accurate information. Gross exaggeration of the extent and severity of hardships in America will not benefit society, the taxpayers, or the poor.

Finally, welfare policy needs to address the causes of poverty, not merely the symptoms. Among families with children, the collapse of marriage and erosion of the work ethic are the principal long-term causes of poverty. When the recession ends, welfare policy must require able-bodied recipients to work or prepare for work as a condition of receiving aid. It should also strengthen marriage in low-income communities rather than ignore and penalize it.

— Robert Rector is Senior Research Fellow in the Domestic Policy Studies Department, and Rachel Sheffield is a Research Assistant in the Richard and Helen DeVos Center for Religion and Civil Society, at The Heritage Foundation.

Is this how you thought the poor among us lived? I don't have a wide screen tv or a plasma either. I also don't have an X-Box or PS2.

[howlnmad]

I have most of the things listed (no A/C, no TiVo and no big screen TV). Do I consider myself poor... no. Back before '08 we were living well with two incomes. The recession hit and my wife lost her job and my pay was cut to damn near half. We struggle at times to make ends meet, winter is the worse. Would I be sad if we lost her car or the 4 wheeler or the boat (boats paid for) or the cable... probably. Would it send me over the edge... no. I've always been a worker and provider and don't plan to stop now. If the census bureau calls me poor then maybe the wrong folks are making that decission.

[HunterAlpha1]

rich and poor are states of mind. howlnmad is richer than most billionaires

[H-D]

I work my butt off to provide for my kids and wife it makes me madder n a hornet to see people who do nothing livin' high on the hog.. I saw a woman today in a suv that was at least 10 model years newer than mine (that I paid for with the sweat of my brow) with an Obama08 sticker on one side and a sticker on the other that said " PROSPERITY IS MY BIRTHRIGHT ! " and I thought to myself what kind of philosophy is that? that you have the right to prosperity by being born ....


pros·per·i·ty
   [pro-sper-i-tee]
noun, plural -ties.
1. a successful, flourishing, or thriving condition, especially in financial respects; good fortune.

[JLA]

I do alright.

I grew up in a very poor family and vowed to myself under silent oath id never see my own children forced to eat ketchup and mayonaise sandwiches because there was nothing else in the house. That id work, to my death if necessary, to provide for them everything theyd ever need and as much as I could afford of that they wanted..

As it turns out, they actually like katchup and mayo sandwiches and eat them on toast pretty regularly, and when i buy them stuff they usually have more fun witht he box it came in..

Go figure. My kids are pros at being poor and theyve never experienced it.

[howlnmad]

HunterAlpha1, thank you, I take that as a compliment as I'm sure it was meant. It makes me happy to see so many others here that share the same morals and values as I do. As long as I have my family, (wife, 4 great kids and 4 beautiful grandkids) and health, I do feel like the richest man alive. Like Josh, my childhood was poor at times, I remember having toast and gravy for supper often. Would I let my family... not a chance. We eat what I hunt, I garden and can vegies. I can raise hogs and poultry too. I guess what I'm saying is, if I had hardly any material things, I'd still be happy.

[Az_gun_gal123*]

I've worked all my life - the last 20 years, tho' I stayed home with our daughter. hubby made more than me so he kept working. We are the working class in America- not rich by dollars but wealthy. We managed to hang onto our home where we raised her. funny - kids these days. She does not want to inherit a pay off home! what I would not have given if I would have had a home handed to me. county lowered taxes across the board. every bit helps but I'm a woman who cooks from scratch. I can make a supper out of air. grin

[Az_gun_gal123*]

i grew up poor a cops kid does. we had a roof over our heads & food on the table but he worked very hard for that. his dream? wasn't big. 1. to leave this earth owing no man 2. to pay for his own funeral. He got both. (without taking charity). I'm writing a book about his life & work, nearly done.

[Fast Forward]

We have some (income Affordable) Apartments in the Area,,90% drive a newer car than i do,,,

[Bobitis]

Originally Posted by howlnmad

I have most of the things listed (no A/C, no TiVo and no big screen TV). Do I consider myself poor... no. Back before '08 we were living well with two incomes. The recession hit and my wife lost her job and my pay was cut to damn near half. We struggle at times to make ends meet, winter is the worse. Would I be sad if we lost her car or the 4 wheeler or the boat (boats paid for) or the cable... probably. Would it send me over the edge... no. I've always been a worker and provider and don't plan to stop now. If the census bureau calls me poor then maybe the wrong folks are making that decission.

The quintessential answer for anyone worth their salt.

Spot on howlnmad! Poor according to whom? When ya get beat down, the good man stands up and provides. It's called PRIDE. It's called HUMILITY. It's called PERSONAL ACCOUNTABILITY. It's also known as INTEGRITY.

Ya got it or ya don't. I don't need anyone elses poll to determine my self worth.

[hogger129]

stop handing them things and they'll be forced to provide for themselves

[geds]

This report is suspect. The quote:

"The vast majority of the homes or apartments of the poor are in good repair."

can easily be disputed by driving through the poor part of town. I noticed yesterday as I was going to one of my favorite restaurants for lunch how almost every house was in disrepair.

If the author can make sure blatant errors in one statement, I certainly wonder about the accuracy of the rest!

[millwright]

Guess I rank below the "One's" "poor" demarcation then ! >MW

[texasred777]

By all of today's standards, my family was poor. Both Mom and Dad worked. At times the textile mill was on 'short time'. That meant from 15 to maybe 30 hours per week. The wages paid were considered a lot lower than the pay in larger cities. The mill was the only industry for many years in the town of Hillsboro, TX. I was born in '42 and Mom and Dad owned a 99 acre farm with a pear, peach, persimon, and pecan orchards about 9 miles from Hillsboro. We had a flock of chickens, several hogs, and around 15 to 20 head of cattle. Dad drove 9 miles each way to the mill weekdays and in season, peddled fruit to the country market in Waco, TX, on weekends. Dad sold the farm and bought a house in Hillsboro in 1944. He continued to work at the mill. After my sis was born in 1946, my mom stayed home to raise us until we were about 2 and 5 years old. We had bought another house just down the street from Dad's sister and her family. We stayed with my aunt while Mom went back to work in the mill. The mill was only about 5 blocks from home. We no longer owned (or needed) a car. They walked us to Aunt Ethel's house, then they walked on to the mill. In the evening, they came by and got us and we went home. Although we lived inside the city-limits, we had a large garden, a cow and calf, 2 to 4 hogs, and about 15 to 20 chickens. We never went hungery. A lot of the garden crop was canned and stored in the pantry each year. It took about a year to get the old house fixed up inside and painted outside. AND, a small bedroom turned into a bathroom. We had an 'outhouse' about 50 yards from the house that was used until the bathroom was finished. Although we lived on the 'west side of town', and were considered poor; I never thought that I was deprived of anything that I needed and got a LOT of things that I just 'wanted'. I remember several times that the mill was only operating 2 1/2 days a week and things got a little rough. Even then we always had plenty to eat and decent clothes to wear. I married when I was 20 years old; my wife was 16. We saw some really hard times as far as keeping the bills paid; but we never were hungery. We always managed to keep the bills paid enough to keep the creditors away. We married in '63 and managed to get by. In 1978 I changed jobs (again) and we were able to make the payments on all the debts for about 8 years. When my employer filed for bankruptcy, and my last 3 pay checks 'bounced'; it got pretty tight for a few weeks. I borrowed some money from a friend and used it to start working for myself. I worked 10 years before getting disgusted with the long hours, on call 24/7, and doing most of my own bookkeepping. I sold my stock to a competitor and about a month later went to work for him in '95. In '97 our oldest daughter died of cancer. She was still living at home. I continued to work until I retired in 2004. We had a 3 bedroom, 2 bath, mobile home and an acre of land paid in full and all of the other debts were paid. Also we had replaced the major appliances during the last 8 or 9 months. Everything seemed to be working ok. The youngest daughter had married and had a son, and our son was still at home after graduating from highschool. Yes, I've seen some hard times a few times during my life; but never considered myself as being 'poor'. After my wife died on '06, I moved here to Idaho to be near my son, daughter, son-in-law, and grandson. I'm 69, some health issues, on social security, AND NOT GOING HUNGERY!!!!!

[texasred777]

Oh! And I NEVER drew 'unemployment', though I have been without a job several times. The longest I spent looking for a job without finding one was almost 2 weeks. If a man really wanted a job he could find something to work at, even if the pay was poor and the job 'sucked'. I have worked several jobs that were pathetic for a while until I found something better. With our current administration, it would be different. I really find it hard to believe that the USA can be in such trouble. I know a lot of men, and women, that have been looking for work for over a year. This is something we have got to change with the election in 2012!!!!!!

[JLA]

Ive never drawn unemployment or any sort of welfare benefits either. And im damn proud of it. Never been without a job either. I have always left one for a better one, no down time between and ive managed to prove myself valuable enough at each gig to dodge the layoffs that have happened. I have been very fortunate.

[terryu1]

I also am OK and do all right. I am not "rich" by any stretch but comfortable. That is the most important thing is if you are comfortable. I have seen many families with 6 kids on low income who have little but are the happiest people in the world. It is not just the income level but the "comfort" factor.

[carver]

Happiness is a state of mind! I grew up on welfare, so I know what it's like to be poor, and that is not what I am. I don't own an X Box, a big screen TV, or a lot of the things mentioned in the article. These people are trying to create a measuring stick, and that stick will be used against the people of the U.S.

The Great Depression is often called a “defining moment” in the twentieth-century history of the United States. Its most lasting effect was a transformation of the role of the federal government in the economy. The long contraction and painfully slow recovery led many in the American population to accept and even call for a vastly expanded role for government, though most businesses resented the growing federal control of their activities. The federal government took over responsibility for the elderly population with the creation of Social Security and gave the involuntarily unemployed unemployment compensation. The Wagner Act dramatically changed labor negotiations between employers and employees by promoting unions and acting as an arbiter to ensure “fair” labor contract negotiations. All of this required an increase in the size of the federal government. During the 1920s, there were, on average, about 553,000 paid civilian employees of the federal government. By 1939 there were 953,891 paid civilian employees, and there were 1,042,420 in 1940. In 1928 and 1929, federal receipts on the administrative budget (the administrative budget excludes any amounts received for or spent from trust funds and any amounts borrowed or used to pay down the debt) averaged 3.80 percent of GNP while expenditures averaged 3.04 percent of GNP. In 1939, federal receipts were 5.50 percent of GNP, while federal expenditures had tripled to 9.77 percent of GNP. These figures provide an indication of the vast expansion of the federal government’s role during the depressed 1930s.

http://www.econlib.org/library/Enc/GreatDepression.html

[geds]

You do realize that you pay unemployment insurance (not a tax) and that your employer also pays unemployment insurance for you? Taking unemployment benefits is no different than making a claim with your insurance agency on a wrecked car or damaged home. There is no shame (or shouldn't be) for any of those circumstances.

And to be proud that you suffered through by not making a claim you were entitled to is like saying I decided not to file a claim on my house that burned down because I can tough it out! You sacrificed for the benefit of the insurance company.

[carver]

Any thing that the Federal Government, or State Government, takes out of your check is a tax!

[ampaterry]

Hunter is right - Rich or poor IS a state of mind.
We've seen days when we had no money, back when I was an E3 in the service and we lived in the Alaskan economy.
But the only time we were HUNGRY was during the Alaska flood after I had been discharged and had a civilian job. We had money then, but it was in the bank, under water, and the only food was that being SOLD by the American Red Cross. They would not take a check.
I've been a lumberjack, pipefitter, repo-man, electrician, lab tech, retired as a Senior Design Engineer, and worked a dozen mundane jobs between those. I did what I had to do. Our kids were ELIGABLE for free lunches, we have been ELIGABLE for food stamps - but never took either, because we didn't need the help.

[jack404]

i'n in the same boat here , i had to go to renew my veterans card , and the office stated i was eleigable for this that and the other , i explained that i get extra income from fox hides and other income ( no profits from SBGO yet but i supply the troops here free ) and do a bit here and there , some fencing for folks , gun repairs and if or when allowed , i'll make some more flinters for export ,

the welfare folks said they knew that and i was STILL eligible , no wonder the permanantly on welfare mob drive new cars ..

i eat better than most working folks i know thanks to hunting and gardening so i save money

i have way more fun as home made BP and ball is cheap ( mind you the raufoss stuff is like $13 a shot so thats a bit silly but ya gotta cut loose once in a while )

and a nice dinner at the RSL once or twice a month .. $25 a head or so ( plus a 1/2 bottle of wine for the Girly and maybe 3-4 schooners for myself so maybe $80 on a big night including the show )

i live pretty damn good ,

but i'm firmly in the belief the Good Lord honours me with this life ,

i'd hate to be one of these useless know nothing Godless cant work parasites who are perpetually broke ..

[texasred777]

When I stated that I had never filed for unemployment, I did NOT mean it as something to be 'proud' of doing. I just meant that I had never needed to file. As I said, I believe that about 2 weeks was the longest that I ever looked for a job before finding one. It was not like it is today. Jobs were scarce at times, but one could be found if you looked hard enough. I'm not certain about today's job market. It appears that openings for jobs are just not to be had. I hear of a job here and there, but most of the time it's in a larger city, instead of here in this smaller town.
I wrote quite a bit about past conditions; now, let me update a little. My daughter became disabled in late '08, and her husband has been on disability of several years. She applied for disability in early '09 and was turned down twice. Finally she was diagnosed with fibromyalgia. It's bad enough that the only times she has been out of the house during the last 18 months or so has been for doctors visits, ER, and one court date. They were on the verge of losing their home in early '10 after the phone was disconnected and threats to turn off the lights, water, and gas were being received. We saw a way to possibly save things by pooling our resources, so I moved in with them. Everything worked out wonderfully. We managed to pay all the back bills and have plenty to eat. Last June, my daughter was awarded disability and things have greatly improved. We added another bedroom and a handicapped bathroom; got enough parts together to build each of us a computer. I have my daughter's computer connected to the tv so she can watch tv or 'compute' using the tv as her monitor. About the only activities she had before was tv and word-find puzzles. This has really opened up a whole new world for her. We still don't have money to do a lot of the things that we would like to do; BUT, we're not going hungery, have good shelter, clothing, transportation, and each other. No, we're not 'poor', just a little finacially handicapped when it comes to buying some of the things that we 'want', not 'need'. Red

[herohog]

We went from "Comfortable" (just under 100k/year combined income) to "All but homeless" over night December 17, 2009. I became disabled and we lost our home, SUV and everything we could sell. Our only income was the pittance my wife made as a Nanny and the whopping 10% disability I was drawing from the VA as an E4 ($123/month).

After a year and several months, we have my VA disability increased to 20% and we FINALLY got Social Security Disability at 100% which, along with what my wife makes at $10/hour sitting with the elderly/ill is JUST enough to live on but there is NO slack and we aren't saving a dime and our saving account is at a whopping $10.02.

In the time it took to get my Social Security, we lived with whoever could put us up. For several months that included living in a storage area with no windows, no A/C and the only heat was provided by tiny electric space heaters. We used a portable toilet as well and had no bathtub but did have a shower.

If it weren't for the VA, I wouldn't be here. They provide my meds and all of my health care which is significant. Back when I was employed and had good insurance, I was spending better than $15,000 a year out of pocket on myself alone.

I know poor. I know how bad our healthcare system is. I know how corrupt our government is. I know how people cheat "the system" and live well where an honest guy like myself is left to starve and rot for following the rules...

[Juker]

It's not how much money we have - it's how we spend it.

"Never equate money with success. The world abounds with wealthy people who are miserable failures as human beings."

The problem in this world of entitlement is that if you don't have a big screen, Xbox, smartphone, etc., you're poor, and you're certainly entitled to have those things, right? Well, I'm not poor, and I don't have them. I just don't want them.

And I look at actors and singers and "athletes" making millions per year, and so many of their lives are a complete trainwreck. Wouldn't trade my life for theirs for any amount of money, nossiree.