Arming Teachers

Discussion in 'The Constitutional & RKBA Forum' started by Marlin, Sep 7, 2004.

  1. Marlin

    Marlin *TFF Admin Staff Chief Counselor*

    Joined:
    Mar 27, 2003
    Messages:
    13,850
    Location:
    At SouthernMoss' side forever!
    This commentary from the National Revue picked up by WorldNetDaily today is refreshing in advancing the theory of being armed is the best protection.

    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~


    Follow the Leader

    Israel and Thailand set an example by arming teachers.


    September 02, 2004
    By David Kopel

    Islamist terrorists in Beslan, Russia, are currently holding hundreds of children hostage, threatening to execute them. No one knows how this horrible situation will end; but we do know that it could have been prevented. Decades ago, Israel adopted a policy that swiftly ended terrorist attacks against schools. Earlier this year, Thailand adopted a similar approach. It is politically incorrect, but it does have the advantage of saving the lives of children and teachers. The policy? Encourage teachers to carry firearms.

    Muslim extremists in Thailand’s southern provinces of Narathiwat, Yala, and Pattani have been carrying out a terrorist campaign, seeking to create an Islamic state independent of Thailand, whose population is predominantly Buddhist.

    Most teachers are Buddhists, and they have been a key target of the terrorists, who have also perpetrated arsons against dozens of schools.

    As reported by the Associated Press (“Thailand allows teachers in restive south to carry guns for protection”) on April 27, 2004, “Interior Minister Bhokin Bhalakula ordered provincial governors to give teachers licenses to buy guns if they want to even though it would mean bringing firearms into the classrooms when the region's 925 schools reopen May 17 after two months of summer holiday.”

    The A.P. article explained: “Pairat Wihakarat, the president of a teachers’ union in the three provinces, said more than 1,700 teachers have already asked for transfers to safer areas. Those who are willing to stay want to carry guns to protect themselves, he said.”

    Gun-control laws in Thailand are extremely strict, and are being tightened even more because of three school shootings (perpetrated by students) that took place in a single week in June 2003. Two students were killed.

    But though Thailand’s government is extremely hostile to gun ownership in general, it has recognized that teachers ought to be able to safeguard their students and themselves.

    Will Thailand’s new strategy work? It did in Israel, as David Schiller detailed in an interview with Jews for the Preservation of Firearms Ownership. Schiller was born in West Germany and moved to Israel, where he served in the military as a weapons specialist. He later returned to Germany, and was hired as a counterterrorism expert by the Berlin police office, as well as by police forces of other German cities. For a while he worked in the terrorism research office of the RAND corporation, and for several years he published a German gun magazine.

    Schiller recalls that Palestine Liberation Organization attacks on Israeli schools began during Passover 1974. The first attack was aimed at a school in Galilee. When the PLO terrorists found that it was closed because of Passover weekend, they murdered several people in a nearby apartment building.

    Then, on May 15, 1974, in Maalot:


    Three PLO gunmen, after making their way through the border fence, first shot up a van load full of workers returning from a tobacco factory (incidentally these people happened to be Galilee Arabs, not Jews), then they entered the school compound of Maalot. First they murdered the housekeeper, his wife and one of their kids, then they took a whole group of nearly 100 kids and their teachers hostage. These were staying overnight at the school, as they were on a hiking trip. In the end, the deadline ran out, and the army’s special unit assaulted the building. During the rescue attempt, the gunmen blew their explosive charges and sprayed the kids with machine-gun fire. 25 people died, 66 wounded.



    Israel at the time had some strict gun laws, left over from the days of British colonialism, when the British rulers tried to prevent the Jews from owning guns.

    After vigorous debate, the government began allowing army reservists to keep their weapons with them. Handgun carry permits were given to any Israeli with a clean record who lived in the most dangerous areas: Judea, Samaria, and Gaza.

    All over Israel, guns became pervasive in the schools:


    Teachers and kindergarten nurses now started to carry guns, schools were protected by parents (and often grandpas) guarding them in voluntary shifts. No school group went on a hike or trip without armed guards. The Police involved the citizens in a voluntary civil guard project “Mishmar Esrachi,” which even had its own sniper teams. The Army’s Youth Group program, “Gadna”, trained 15 to 16-year-old kids in gun safety and guard procedures and the older high-school boys got involved with the Mishmar Esrachi. During one noted incident, the “Herzliyah Bus massacre” (March ’78, hijacking of a bus, 37 dead, 76 wounded), these youngsters were involved in the overall security measures in which the whole area between North Tel Aviv and the resort town of Herzlyiah was blocked off, manning roadblocks with the police, guarding schools kindergartens, etc.


    After a while, “When the message got around to the PLO groups and a couple infiltration attempts failed, the attacks against schools ceased.”

    This is not to say that Palestinian terrorists never target schools. In late May 2002, an Israeli teacher shot a suicide terrorist before he could harm anyone.

    On May 31, 2002, as reported by Israel National News, a terrorist threw a grenade and began shooting at a kindergarten in Shavei Shomron. Then, instead of closing in on the children, he abruptly fled the kindergarten and began shooting up the nearby neighborhood. Apparently he realized that the kindergarten was sure to have armed adults, and that he could not stay at the school long enough to make sure he actually murdered someone.

    Unfortunately for the terrorist, “David Elbaz, owner of the local mini-market, gave chase and killed him with gunshots. In addition to several grenades and the weapon the terrorist carried on him, security sweeps revealed several explosive devices that he had intended to detonate during the thwarted attack.”

    People can spend months and years studying the “root causes” of terrorism, and pondering the merits of the grievances of Islamic terrorists in Malaysia, Israel, and Russia. But it’s fair to say that schoolchildren and teachers are not legitimate targets even of people who have legitimate grievances.

    No one knows if civilized nations will ever eliminate the root causes of terrorism. But we do know that terrorist attacks on schools and schoolchildren could be almost completely eliminated in a very short time — if every nation at risk of terrorist attacks on schools began following the lead of Thailand and Israel.

    Adults have a duty to protect children. In Beslan at this very moment, seven people are dead, and hundreds more are in deadly peril, because the teachers lacked the tools to stop the evildoers. If we are really serious about gun laws that protect “the children,” then it seems clear that — whatever other gun laws a society adopts — every civilized nation at risk of terrorist attack ought to ensure that armed teachers can protect innocent children.

    David Kopel is research director of the Independence Institute.

    © 2004 WorldNetDaily
  2. armedandsafe

    armedandsafe Guest

    Logical and true. Two items which never affect a gun-banner.

    Pops
  3. Tony Mig

    Tony Mig New Member

    Joined:
    Jul 5, 2003
    Messages:
    716
    Location:
    The Sorprano State
    It amazes me what politically correct liberals will trust a certain individual to do, and not to do.
    Teachers are trusted to care for, nurture and educate children, but they won't trust them to carry a gun to protect those children.
    Airline Pilots are trusted to fly hundreds of people, thousands of miles in a multi million dollar aircraft, but not to carry a gun to protect those same people.
    Truck Drivers are trusted to drive all our consumer goods (including flamable and hazardous materials) from ocean to ocean, but not to carry a gun to protect these goods from highjackers, or the extremely large, heavy & high powered truck from becoming a highway killing machine.
    Firemen are trusted to protect people's homes, business', and lives, but not with a gun.
    Policeman are trusted to protect us with a gun, but the minute he/she has to use that weapon to protect the law abiding, they are burried in internal investigations, mountains of reports & other paperwork, and usually given desk duty until some bleeding heart liberal judge decideds his/her actions were justified.

    Lawyers, liberals, and political correctness has destroyed this nation..... :rolleyes:
Similar Threads
Forum Title Date
The Constitutional & RKBA Forum Arming MS schools Feb 17, 2013
The Constitutional & RKBA Forum disarming the people..... Jul 25, 2012
The Constitutional & RKBA Forum OBAMA SIGNS BILLS AND CREATES NEW LAWS DISARMING AMERICANS May 1, 2009
The Constitutional & RKBA Forum South Dakota house passes bill allowing teachers to be armed Jan 30, 2013
The Constitutional & RKBA Forum S.C. consitering allowing teachers to carry at schools Dec 19, 2012

Share This Page