The Myth of the Bear Gun?

Discussion in 'General Discussion' started by garydude, Jun 26, 2012.

  1. garydude

    garydude Member

    About two years ago I was hunting in northern AZ and came across some cool bear tracks while hunting turkey. I returned with my wife to show her the tracks, and to my amazement, the bear had been there again as his tracks were placed on top of mine that I put there about two hours before! This kind of freaked me out, so I went and bought a 44 mag, as I didn't think my 45 or 357 would have enough to put down a bear reliably. Now, don't get me wrong, I wanted one anyways and it seemed like as good of an excuse that I could have.

    I just read this article this morning. It seems that having a bear gun isn't such a bad idea after all. Here's the link, followed by a pic I took of the bear tracks.

    By Mike Sakal, Tribune | 0 comments

    Arizona Game and Fish Department wildlife officers and personnel from the U.S. Department of Agriculture’s Wildlife Services lethally removed three black bears over the weekend, following a trio of bear attacks within the last month and resulting in the closures of campgrounds near Payson.

    Killing the bears also were in response to attacks within the last month involving three Valley residents — an Apache Junction woman on May 31, a Glendale man late June 21 and Tempe man on June 22, according to information from Arizona Game and Fish.

    Pedro Baca, 30, of Tempe, was attacked about 5 a.m. on Sunday at the Ponderosa campground while sleeping. Baca remains in critical condition at Scottsdale Healthcare Osborn hospital, according to information from Arizona Game and Fish.

    The first of two bears killed on Sunday was a young adult male weighing around 160 pounds, and the second bear was a very large female that weighed approximately 300 pounds. Dogs had tracked the bears from a scent trail near the campground. Officials first had lethally removed a bear on Friday when it was trailed by hounds, close to the site of the second attack near Tonto Village and Tonto Creek Fish Hatchery.

    The removal of the bears also has caused the Ponderosa Campground and two others to be closed, possibly until July 15 while the incidents are under review, according to Game and Fish. The Ponderosa Campground is 12 miles northeast of Payson.

    The Sharp Creek and Christopher Creek campgrounds are closed and campers have been evacuated, officials said.

    The Christopher Creek Campground is 19 miles northeast of Payson on Arizona 260 while the Sharp Creek Campground is 23 miles northeast of Payson on the south side of Arizona 260.

    Game and Fish officials said it was necessary to lethally remove the bears because of the aggressive, predatory behavior the animals which may have been involved in attacking all three victims during the past month. The only means of testing for rabies is by having the animal’s carcass.

    Game and Fish has conducted forensic investigations on all three victims’ personal belongings and camping equipment to recover DNA samples. Those samples, as well as some tissue from the bears that were removed, were scheduled to be flown to the Wyoming Game and Fish Forensic and Fish Health Laboratory on Tuesday for analysis to determine whether the bears were the ones responsible for the earlier maulings.

    “Until we receive the results of the DNA analysis, we will not know whether these three recent attacks can be attributed to one bear or three different bears. DNA examination is critical in this case for helping prove or disprove a link between the attacks,” said Rod Lucas, regional supervisor for Game and Fish in an agency-issued statement.

    Game and Fish set bear culvert traps following the first incident on May 31 involving an Apache Junction woman, but had yet to catch a bear. A trap was set in the Ponderosa Campground at the time of the latest attack.

    “By setting culvert traps in the area where the attacks have occurred, we are more likely to catch the problem bear and not other bears that are not creating public safety issues,” Lucas said. “Our wildlife officers chose their profession because of their love for wildlife and the outdoors. They do not enjoy destroying animals, but the burden of public safety and active management of wildlife dictates an aggressive approach, and efforts will continue until the offending animal is found or it is no longer feasible to continue operations.”

    With the state’s drought and scarce wildlife food resources, more and more wildlife are moving into areas that are on the fringe of wildlands, looking for food. Bears are particularly attracted to campground areas where they often find easy access to garbage and food sources.

    Bear attacks on humans are rare despite Arizona’s robust population of 2,500 to 3,000 bears. Sunday’s attack is only the 10th documented bear attack in Arizona since 1990, but the third this year.

    Slightly less than a year ago, Lana Hollingsworth, 61, of Gilbert died in late July days after she was mauled by a bear in Pinetop. Hollingsworth volunteered in three capacities with the Gilbert Fire Department and dressed up as a clown to provide humor therapy at local hospitals.

    For more information about the closure of the campgrounds and areas near them, visit or call the Payson Ranger District offices at (928) 474-7900.

    Attached Files:

  2. Caneman

    Caneman Active Member

    Oct 22, 2010
    i always carry mine when in bear country, SW 629, gives me a sense of security... got 4 animal threats in the mountains where I hunt/hike: black bear, mtn lion, rattler, and homie da dope grower and the last one is the most worrisome to me...

  3. carver

    carver Moderator Supporting Member

    Down here where I live we do have lions, but very, very, few. No bears either, but we do have snakes. The ones that crawl on the ground I can deal with, it's the one's growing the pot that make me tread carefully! I'm armed at all times anyway!
  4. tuckerd1

    tuckerd1 Moderator Supporting Member

    We are having more lion and black bear sightings every year in N.E. Alabama. Of course we have plenty of snakes! The two legged kind too!
  5. MSGT-R

    MSGT-R Active Member

    Feb 27, 2011
    Black Bears like to sneak into the backyards of foothill homes in the Los Angeles area to eat pet food and take a soak in the pools or jacuzzis.

    No joke.
  6. RunningOnMT

    RunningOnMT New Member

    Nov 19, 2008
    Akron, Ohio
    Just make sure you grind off the front sight blade on any gun you use to hunt bear.
  7. dhenry132

    dhenry132 New Member

    Jan 8, 2010
    I just bought another S&W 500 4 incher. I lost the first on a couple years ago in a almost bear attach in AK.
    Was fishing enjoying life when the this monster brown bear charged out of the brush from about 100 feet. Damn thing looked like a 747 with teeth coming at us. I managed to get off two shots with the 500. Never could find any evidence that I even hit it. Maybe the muzzle blast scared it off. Which ever one I'm grateful. I think now, if they made a 600 I would buy it. The first 500 I had was given to the fellow I fish with to use. He put his 454 up in the safe.
  8. Buckshot

    Buckshot Active Member

    May 5, 2009
    Southern AZ
    The .44 Mag should be more than adequate for blacks, with some adjustment for the size and disposition of the bear. (Said adjustment not possible at the time of course. Sorry. :) Fortunately we don't grow them especially large in AZ.) A few well-placed rounds from a .357 would probably work just about as well on most of our smaller bears. I remember a guy that killed one hereabouts a few years back when it opened his tent. He used a Ruger Blackhawk in .44-40. (Interestingly more people are mauled and/or killed by blacks than grizzlies. Probably a statistical outcome of far greater numbers of people in closer contact with far greater numbers of blacks.)

    I'll never forget one of the most sobering things I ever read about defending yourself against a bear attack with a handgun. An experienced hunter and guide said to imagine that the bear was an NFL quarterback at the same distance. He is going to wind up and throw the ball at your head. Your job is to shoot the football before it smashes you in the face. :eek: Yeah...gulp. He was talking specifically about a charging grizzly, but it sure is something to think about.
    Last edited: Jun 27, 2012
  9. carver

    carver Moderator Supporting Member

    We have had a few black bears come into the NW corner of LA, by way of AR, but they get trapped fast, and sent back to AR! Haven't heard about any in the NE corner of TX, but I have to believe that there are a few. If I should see one in the woods, you can bet your last dollar that I will give him the right of way! We spend a lot of time in the Ozark mountains, camping, and just sight seeing. We have seen plenty of the black bears up there. We spent a week in Yellowstone National Park, and I had the biggest hand gun I own with me, a .44 mag. I woke up one morning with a Buffalo just outside my tent, 2 feet! Let me tell you right now that I was sure thinking that I needed a much bigger gun!
  10. soundguy

    soundguy Well-Known Member

    May 8, 2012
    more bear sightings here in fl too.. mating season I believe...
  11. Petergunn

    Petergunn Member

    Jan 17, 2011
    ohio's northcoast
    or buy a small gun:D
  12. MadScotsMan

    MadScotsMan Member

    Jun 25, 2012
    We have had a black bear in our yard twice in the past week and have spotted another (much larger) about two miles from here. I don't walk the woods without packing a firearm. Once finances allow, (been out of work far too long) I'd like to pick up at least a .44 mag, but preferrably either a .454 or .500. I'd much rather have too much gun than too little in a situation like that.
  13. gvw3

    gvw3 Well-Known Member Supporting Member

    Oct 16, 2011
    Chicago IL Area
    I do have a 44 mag handgun but I don't see to many bears around here. We did have a mountain lion right in the center of Chicago last year. Cop's had to shoot it.
Similar Threads
Forum Title Date
General Discussion 'Mythbusters' cannonball hits minivan in Dublin Dec 6, 2011
General Discussion Movie gun myths Jul 24, 2011
General Discussion Mythbusters Jun 17, 2010
General Discussion Mythbusters, you should be ashamed Jul 28, 2009
General Discussion New mythbusters episode hurry!!! Jun 10, 2009