Sometimes my Okie talk gets the best of me even when I type ! Will add another plastic bag tonight . I got a Dragoon and thought maybe of trying to shove it into the holster but afraid it might make it to big and loose . My Colt Walker sure would ! If you ever tried carry Walker or a Dragoon for very long you will know why the carried them on the saddle ! A pommel holster I think were called .Yes. you did. The only reason I noticed is because it happened to me last week , same word. LOL
I've used Skidmore's Leather Cream. It works good on saddles, bags and holsters. You may want to keep using that plastic bag a while longer before trying anything else. Better yet, wrap it in two bags tonight.